Is it possible to use feedback op amps to build a comparator. A voltage comparator based on opamp is shown in the figure.


  •  Is it possible to use feedback op amps to build a comparator. Feedback allows the circuit designer to control the gain of the op-amp. We can use 741, LM311, LM324, LM393 opamp to make a voltage comparator circuit. We consider first a simple op-amp application used to interface an analog signal to a digital device: the Schmitt trigger, a 1-bit analog to digital converter (in which the op-amp is used as a comparator). The open collector structure Using that configuration? No, absolutely not. Nov 9, 2024 · Op-amp comparators are circuits that use an operational amplifier (op-amp) in an open-loop configuration (without negative feedback) to compare two input voltages. This use changes the op-amp from a linear device into a “bistable” device, that is, one that has only two possible output values. Update your notes. Often, this is when you only need one simple comparator and you have a “spare” op amp in a quad op amp package. Comparators Sometimes, you want to use an op-amp in its saturated mode – where the output is pushed either as far positive or as far negative as it can go. Nov 9, 2023 · Figure 2 shows an op-amp hysteresis circuit. Both inverting and non-inverting amplifiers are covered with clear examples, walking you through the effects of feedback, and how simple calculations can be used to determine gain. The simplest feedback configurations for an Op-amp Comparator Circuit The comparator is an electronic decision making circuit that makes use of an operational amplifiers very high gain in its open-loop state, that is, there is no feedback resistor. # Sep 1, 2025 · What is a Comparator Circuit? A comparator circuit compares two input voltages and forces its output to a logic-like high or low state. The result is a comparator: Beyond the Op Amp— Designing With IC Comparators Generally speaking, an op amp doesn’t make for a good comparator. For now, note that it is best to avoid trying to use an op amp as a comparator, so these devices are convenient if your application requires both a comparator and an op amp and minimizing printed circuit board space is critical. Mar 14, 2012 · Many of you (and I, too) occasionally use an op amp as a comparator. Is it possible to use feedback op-amps to build a comparator? Describe in your own words how is it possible to take an analog signal and determine an equivalent digital signal. To most people, a comparator is merely an op amp without feedback. Op-amp requires more time to come out of the saturation, so these kinds of circuits are preferred at low frequency applications. Oct 14, 2022 · Using an op-amp as a comparator is easy and a commonly accepted practice. The comparator will compare the input signal (Vin) to the threshold voltage (Vth). Jul 1, 2014 · Op amps circuits almost always use negative feedback: feedback is the most important principle of modern analog circuit design. Open-loop means there is no negative feedback. The op amp is a highly versatile and cost-effective device as it can be used to build a wide range of circuits, from simple circuits to more complex ones. By modifying Aug 17, 2022 · In this video, we show you how to use an op amp as a comparator circuit- one of the many applications of op amps. To test the op-amp as a comparator, we will build a small and simple working circuit. So to make things a little bit easier for all, here is a list of some of the “Basic” Op-amp building blocks we can use to create different analogue circuits and filters. This op-amp is an inverting comparator with Vin connecting to the V– (inverting input) while the positive terminal (V+) connects to the midpoint of the voltage divider (R2 and R3) forming a positive feedback network. Generally speaking, an op amp doesn’t make for a good comparator. By designing an operational amplifier with the desired gain, we can detect the level at which the peak of the signal has been reached. Very few designers make the mistake of using a comparator as an op amp, because most comparators have open collector output. In addition, op amps are often available in packages of two or four—if you need three op amps and a comparator, it seems pointless to buy four op amps, not use one of them, and then buy a separate comparator. A voltage comparator based on opamp is shown in the figure. View M4D1-2. Fig. 1 The Comparator A comparator is a 1 bit analog to digital converter. 3: Ideal op amp input-output characteristic. Not a single one of those components is placed in a useful way. Aug 24, 2013 · Op-amp Building Blocks for Analogue Amplifier Design Operational Amplifiers, or op-amps for short, are the fundamental analogue building blocks used in electronics designs. Op-amp in open loop configuration goes into saturation. The basic operation of an analog comparator is the generation of binary-valued voltages that switch between the two binary levels when an analog input crosses a threshold voltage (Vth). However, op amps can also be used as comparators, which causes them to operate non-linearly. There are many ways to configure these kinds of circuits and there are many uses for a The performance of op-amps and comparators usually limits the high-frequency application and dynamic range of the overall circuit. Figure 2-2 Amplifier circuit with feedback Op-amps are generally used with negative feedback. Watch for a step-by-step explanation and circuit analysis. This section briefly describes negative feedback. The op-amp’s output rapidly saturates to either the positive or negative supply rail, depending on which input voltage is larger. The op-amp is characterized by an open-loop gain A and let’s assume that the output voltage Vo can go all the way to VDD and VEE. Here, an LM358 op-amp is set up as a comparator, and the LM393 is also set up as a comparator. A comparator is designed to produce well-limited output voltages that easily interface with digital logic. There are two types of feedback loops: positive and negative. Aug 22, 2013 · In the next tutorial about Operational Amplifier basics, we will use negative feedback connected around the op-amp to produce a standard closed-loop amplifier circuit called an Inverting Amplifier circuit that produces an output signal which is 180 o “out-of-phase” with the input. However, the best advice on using an op amp as comparator is very simple—don’t! Chapter 13: Comparators So far, we have used op amps in their normal, linear mode, where they follow the op amp Golden Rules (no input current to either input, no voltage difference between the inputs). Start by shutting off the power supplies and assemble the circuit. The high voltage gain enables it to resolve minimal differences in the input voltage. OPAMP Comparator Circuit: An opamp can be easily configured to act as a voltage comparator. A linear regulator may be based on a series-parallel feedback loop, using an op amp as a controller. When the Vin > Vth the output will drive to the negative supply (GND or logic low in this example). Comparators are specific op-amps circuits that are meant to work in a non-linear mode and can be used as simple logic gates. An op-amp works as a comparator, and the output remains saturated either to VDD or VSS. 3. This type of comparator circuit is useful for detecting events using sensors (light, temperature, pressure, etc. It has a differential analog input and a digital output. Jan 15, 2021 · These circuits used negative feedback, which normally keeps the op amp operating in the linear region. Apr 13, 2013 · In this post, we're going to take a brief look at one way of using an operational amplifier. This document explains the basic electrical characteristics (offset voltage, common-mode input voltage, open gain, commonmode input signal In addition, op amps are often available in packages of two or four—if you need three op amps and a comparator, it seems pointless to buy four op amps, not use one of them, and then buy a separate comparator. A comparator is designed to be used with large differential input voltages, whereas op amps normally operate with their differential input voltage minimized by negative feedback. o Is it possible to use feedback op-amps to build a comparator? A comparator circuit is one that accepts two inputs and provides an output Question: Is it possible to use feedback op-amps to build a comparator? Describe in your own words how is it possible to take an analog signal and determine an equivalent digital signal. The op amp compares a scaled version of the load voltage to a reference voltage. With the huge open-loop gain would simply slam its output to the positive or negative rail with the tiniest input difference. Compatibility with digital logic must be verified while using an op-amp as a comparator. While their performance is generally not as good as a dedicated comparator, for most applications, those that don’t require extreme response times or are strapped in their power requirements, they work well enough. Although this circuit is functional, it is not the final word on comparators. Experiment 4 Comparators, positive feedback, and relaxation oscillators This experiment will continue our investigations of nonlinear analog circuits. Figure 5 in the original article shows an example of a comparator circuit with hysteresis. For this question you will extend the op-amp circuit above into a window comparator. In your own words, describe the difference between analog-to-digital converters using the dual-slope method and the Please answer the discussion questions below: The basic comparator circuit is an op-amp arranged in the open-loop configuration as shown on the circuit of Figure 1. Comparator circuit design with op amps can be tricky for newcomers, but finding the right resources and advice can go a long way. a Jul 16, 2019 · It’s possible to simplify the procedure for designing an op-amp as a comparator into two design steps: Set the threshold voltage using a resistor divider or reference voltage. It suffers from two faults: (1) it is not particularly fast, and (2) it does not use hysteresis. V+ is now the upper and lower thresholds of the comparator set by the R2, and R3. As with the summing amplifier circuit, use the second waveform generator Comparator Circuits & Op-Amps The comparator circuit is very useful for comparing two voltages and detecting the larger or smaller - we look at comparators in general and the issues of using an op amp as a comparator. May 2, 2018 · The simple open-loop op amp comparator was discussed in Chapter 2. May 2, 2018 · With extreme values in the positive feedback network, it is also possible that some shift of the output frequency may occur due to the capacitive and resistive loading effects of the op amp. The open collector structure Op Amp comparator What is a comparator ? A comparator is an electronic circuit that compares the voltage levels of two input signals and produces a binary output indicating which input is higher. Understand the working principle and applications of op amp comparators. The comparator circuit does not use negative feedback, and so purposefully violates Golden Rule 1. The op-amp is allowed to saturate to its maximum and minimum output Op amps can’t exist without feedback, and feedback has inherent stability problems, so feedback and stability are covered in Chapter 5. Mar 2, 2025 · A simple OP-AMP comparator circuit explanation. Op-amp requires phase compensation capacitor for preventing oscillation because it configures a negative feedback circuit in use, while comparator does not require this capacitor because it does not configure negative feedback. Op Amp Comparator An op amp comparator is a circuit that uses an operational amplifier to compare two voltages. What is an Op amp Comparator We've been using an op amp IC probably since we started learning electronics, I am referring to this wonderful little IC 741, through which virtually any comparator based circuit designing becomes Remember that this case will only be possible if negative feedback is applied to the op-amp in the form of applying some component of the output voltage back to the input—specifically the negative input. We will make a comparator circuit with the LM358N op-amp, showing you how to A comparator circuit is basically an operational amplifier without feedback, that is, the op-amp is used in its open-loop configuration, and when the input voltage, V in exceeds a preset reference voltage, V ref, the output changes state. In your own words, describe the difference between analog-to-digital converters using the dual-slope method and the ladder configuration. A voltage comparator can be of two Attempt if you would like a challenge. 1 Introduction Simple comparator circuits are Operational amplifier ,Comparator (Tutorial) This application note explains the general terms and basic techniques that are necessary for configuring application circuits with op-amps and comparators. See its features, pinouts, specifications, and example circuits. Circuits that perform close to perfect mathematical operations (addition, subtraction, integration, and diferentiation ) can be constructed using negative and operational feedback. ) and controlling devices based on sensor inputs. Before diving in, let's take a moment to discuss about the operational amplifier. Aug 7, 2021 · The concept used in designing the comparator is straightforward. Mar 9, 2022 · Is it possible to use feedback op-amps to build a comparator? Short answer – Yes. Describe in your own words how is it possible to take an analog signal and determine an equivalent digital signal. Stability in operational amplifiers is achieved through the application of negative feedback, contrasting with a comparator's design choice to bypass feedback for clear, binary outcomes in threshold detection. Non-linear applications of op-amp: In this type of applications, output is not having a linear relationship with input. Mar 27, 2023 · The most obvious way is to use the generic op-amp as a comparator. The inputs to the comparator can be any […] Operational amplifier ,Comparator (Tutorial) This application note explains the general terms and basic techniques that are necessary for configuring application circuits with op-amps and comparators. When the voltage applied at the non-inverting (‘+’) input of an op amp is higher than the Jun 26, 2018 · Using an op amp as the basis for a comparator circuit provides several advantages over traditional analog designs. Learn about operational amplifier (op-amp) circuits, their fundamental principles, common applications like amplifiers and filters, and explore practical design examples. This algorithm is Some op-amps show an increased quiescent current when the inputs are not equal. If the output voltage is to be limited to the supply rails, then the level2 model is required, otherwise the output will swing to extreme voltages, as the model is deigned to be used with negative feedback, which will inherently limit the voltage. Finally, read about and understand the range detector circuit which makes use of a pair of Op-Amps. In Summary (using technical language): An op-amp, used without any limiting feedback, will amplify the difference between the inputs by the open loop gain. Comparators also work well while being overdriven. Engineering Electrical Engineering Electrical Engineering questions and answers Why is it preferred to use a feedback op amp to build a comparator? 3 The Comparator A comparator is a 1-bit analog-to-digital converter. To achieve optimal performance and avoid additional debugging, an IC comparator is the best bet. Jan 6, 2023 · I am currently using a DIP8 op-amp (Texas Instruments LM358P), but I will be using the SMD op-amp as shown in the schematic from OnSemi. Figure 1. Learn how it works, key components, and examples. You will be using the . As the open loop gain is assumed to be very large then even a very small difference between the inputs will result in the output saturating. 2 Background In this experiment you will examine the properties of several of the most often used op amp circuits. The comparator, also known as a voltage comparator, has a function to detect the high or low voltage with respect to the reference signal. a Op-amp Comparator The comparator is an electronic decision making circuit that makes use of an operational amplifiers very high gain in its open-loop state, that is, there is no feedback resistor. Jun 29, 2022 · A simple comparator can be created using an op amp without negative feedback. The comparator is an electronic decision making circuit that makes use of an operational amplifiers very high gain in its open-loop state, that is, there is no feedback resistor. The comparator is basically a 1-bit analog-to-digital converter: Op-amps are rarely used in the way described above, with the inputs directly driven, unless the goal is to simply figure out which input is more positive (in this case, the op-amp is being used as a comparator). You can improvise one with an op-amp without feedback (comparator op amp circuit), but a dedicated comparator integrated circuit is preferred for speed, input common-mode control, and clean recovery. However, the best advice on using an op amp as comparator is very simple—don’t! In this lab we introduce the operational amplifier (op amp) in switching mode configuration, obtaining a op-amp voltage comparator behavior. Jun 17, 2025 · Discover the key differences between comparators and op-amps, including their functions, output behavior, speed, and ideal applications. They provide unity gain to the applied input signals. Learn when to use each component for optimal analog circuit design. What are comparators in electronics? They compare two voltages and output a digital signal, helping circuits make fast, clear decisions. Op-amp is operated either in open loop condition or with positive feedback. It acts like emitter follower configuration of transistor based amplifiers. Dec 13, 2020 · It also involves understanding how to select the appropriate op amp for a specific application, as well as how to ensure optimal performance from the op amp. Dec 21, 2024 · Learn how op-amp comparator circuits work with practical designs, real-world applications, and step-by-step guidance for voltage detection. docx from ELEC 161 at Excelsior University. The voltage comparator circuit has the purpose of highlighting via two different states of the output voltage, the relative state of the two input voltage. The TLV2302 is an open-drain comparator, while the TLV2702 is a push-pull output comparator. Very few designers make the mistake of using a comparator as an op amp, because most comparators have an open collector output. Jun 4, 2025 · The video then introduces the possible uses for op-amps, including the comparator, and explains how negative feedback can be used. It functions by comparing two voltages and outputting a high or low signal. Learn how to build an op amp comparator circuit with a detailed diagram. The input is a square wave signal from A CMOS 555 timer, which provides fast edges. One of the most important uses of the comparator is in analog to digital conversion. So we can summarise our operational amplifier section with a look at the different types of op-amp circuits we could make and their different configurations discussed throughout this op-amp tutorial section. This circuit introduces us to the use Is it possible to use feedback op-amps to build a comparator? 2. To apply feedback to an amplifier means to feed some of its output back into its input. Oct 20, 2022 · Learn about two integrated circuits, operational amplifiers (op amps) and comparators, and explore the possible pitfalls of using an op-amp as a comparator. Providing a comparator with hysteresis means that its reference depends The objective of this activity is to investigate the voltage comparator, the use of positive feedback and the operation of the Schmitt Trigger configuration. a Chapter 13: Comparators So far, we have used op amps in their normal, linear mode, where they follow the op amp Golden Rules (no input current to either input, no voltage difference between the inputs). In an op-amp circuit with no feedback, there is no corrective mechanism, and the output voltage will saturate with the tiniest amount of differential voltage applied between the inputs. In fact, as we shall see below, comparator circuits often employ positive feedback to ensure that nothing intermediate between the two extreme output states is utilized. Comparator Practice Problems Problems and solutions to build skills in op amp comparator circuits These practice problems show how to analyze and design simple op amp comparator circuits. The "trick" in designing linear op amp circuits is to use of negative feedback to always force (V+ - V-) to be suf - ficiently small so that the amplifier is operating in that very narrow linear region. Here you will find many tutorial articles to learn about op amps. Jul 23, 2025 · The use of Op-amps as a comparator can be seen in the Audio Level Meter to measure the maximum possible values of audio signals. Op-amps are designed to perform mathematical operations like amplification, attenuation, addition, subtraction, integration, and differentiation on analog signals. Using Op amp like Comparator An op amp includes an extremely high open-loop DC gain, meaning that even a small amount of differential input voltage could push the output to one extreme of the supply voltage or to the other extreme. This is true for the majority of comparators, but there are also some refinements and variations. Sep 27, 2020 · On the other hand, when no feedback is applied to the inverting input, the op-amp is said to work in the non-linear regime, we can also say in an open-loop configuration. The output saturating means that the output voltage gets as close to the supply voltage as possible Negative Feedback and Why It's Important Negative feedback is used to stabilize the response of a system without feedback. We have also seen that we can connect resistors A comparator chip has two voltage inputs, and outputs a voltage based on which of the two inputs is higher. Hysteresis provides a margin of safety and “cleans up” switching transitions. Figure 9. 1: Circuit Diagram of… Mar 28, 2012 · In this post I will comprehensively explain how to use any opamp as a comparator in a circuit for comparing a input differentials and producing the corresponding outputs. The positive feedback used in oscillator circuits is always phase-shifted 360 o, while the positive feedback used in comparator circuits has no phase shift at all, being direct-coupled. This week we look at comparators: specialty op-amps which use positive feedback or no feedback. Research some relaxation oscillator circuits, you can make it with just an op-amp, 3 resistors, and a capacitor Comparator One of the important circuits involving op-amps is the so-called analog comparator. Current Feedback Op-Amps: These op-amps use a current feedback architecture instead of voltage feedback, which can provide high bandwidth and fast transient response. There is a simple algorithm for the analysis of an op amp circuit. Taking the op-amp’s output voltage and coupling it to the inverting input is a technique known as negative feedback, and it is the key to having a self-stabilizing system (this is true not only of op-amps, but of any dynamic system in general). Chapters 6 and 7 develop the voltage feedback op amp equations, and they teach the concept of relative stability and com-pensation of potentially unstable op amps. Op-amps are normally used with additional components or connections. The output transistor of open collector comparators is characterized by low VCE for switching heavy loads. It can be used to perform various arithmetic operations, act as an amplifier, buffer, comparator, or as an electronic filter, etc. Reading: Read about using LDRs and Thermistors with a comparator and understand the two examples. For example, positive feedback can be compared to the following cycle: 1) You study hard, and your grades improve. Op amp as comparator. It is recommended that you build this circuit away from the rest of the practical, as you only have 1 LM358 Op-Amp - you must first demonstrate Questions 1 and 2, and then move the LM358 to this circuit for full marks. We can use an operational amplifier as a comparator configuring it in open-loop. a Mar 26, 2021 · Op-amps, also known as operational amplifiers, are used for voltage amplifiers, filters, phase shifts, and more. Operational amplifier ,Comparator (Tutorial) This application note explains the general terms and basic techniques that are necessary for configuring application circuits with op-amps and comparators. Here we will use the comparator in a common configuration that generates a square wave with a variable pulse width. Aug 10, 2021 · Op amp as a Voltage follower Voltage follower is a negative feedback op-amp amplifier circuit. The comparator input signal is applied to the inverting input, so the output will have an inverted polarity. Unity gain means the output voltage will be exactly equal in magnitude with the input voltage. I. Oct 29, 2020 · making a voltage comparator using transistors and other components is quite difficult and makes no sense because we have OPAMPs. Aug 14, 2024 · Introduction to Op-Amps An operational amplifier, or op-amp, is a high-gain electronic voltage amplifier with differential inputs and a single output. The comparison is made using the sign of the difference between the two input voltages, while This is the Op Amp tutorial page of Learning about Electronics. What is a Comparator? The comparator is a circuit that compares one analog signal with another analog signal or a reference voltage and outputs a binary signal based on the comparison. Non-linear op amp circuits that employ positive feedback are also useful. Chapter 13: Comparators So far, we have used op amps in their normal, linear mode, where they follow the op amp Golden Rules (no input current to either input, no voltage difference between the inputs). Refer to this note for guidance when using op-amps and comparators. If you need to use an op amp as a comparator and require hysteresis, you can add an external positive feedback network to implement it. With the very large open-loop gain of the op amp, the output abruptly traverses the entire available voltage range when one input passes the level of the other. Long answer – Comparators are designed to drive circuits with fast and clean switching within an open- loop system at high speed. Sep 28, 2025 · Try LM311 as a differential comparator OP-AMP with a wide range of voltage. 25. The use of conventional operational amplifiers as a substitute for voltage comparators will also be explored. Dec 5, 2017 · Sponsored by: Texas Instruments. Without a thorough understanding of the operation and basic limitation of these components, the circuit designer cannot determine or even predict the actual response of the overall system. Hardware Setup: Comparators are used in different ways, and we will see them in action in future labs. Jul 16, 2021 · LM358 Op-Amp Vs LM393 Comparator - A Practical Example The best way to compare the switching times of an op-amp and comparator is to set up a simple comparator circuit. If it's working now, will there be any difference with between the two? Would there be any difference/benefit if I used a comparator instead? Namely, the one shown floating in the schematic, also by OnSemi. Consider how an Op-Amp can act as a current source or as a current sink and understand the examples given. c7d7 u8g4 0jssfx frynmo j2o56l h4hwpckn ylymovd hejm bunszm ucdvt6od
Top